Fire insurance and Mountain Living
By Keith Kanady

You’ve decided to live in the Santa Cruz Mountains. You wanted the redwoods and the morning mist. Then you applied for homeowners insurance, and you realized that the insurance companies view our beautiful ridges as a giant pile of kindling.
Welcome to the current insurance landscape, where finding a traditional policy is about as likely as finding a parking spot at Pleasure Point on a sunny Saturday. Most private carriers have ghosted us like a bad date, leaving roughly 11,000 mountain residents clutching our California FAIR Plan policies like a life raft made of very expensive paper.
Speaking of expensive, let’s talk about the FAIR Plan. Starting October 15, they will hike rates by a statewide average of 29.1 percent. In high-hazard mountain areas, our adjustments might make that 29 percent look like a bargain.
The FAIR Plan only covers fire. If a burglar steals your TV or a guest stumbles over a rogue banana slug, you’re going to need a supplementary wraparound policy. It’s like insurance lasagna: layers of premiums just so you can sleep at night.
There is a glimmer of hope. Santa Cruz County has officially been named a “Fire Risk Reduction Community.” This sounds like a fancy merit badge, but it could mean you get a discount. If you’re in a Firewise Community or you’ve spent your spare time hardening your home—things like clearing brush and installing ember-resistant vents—you could snag up to 16.4 percent off the wildfire portion of your policy. It’s the insurance equivalent of getting a gold star for not letting your yard look like a tinderbox.
And if you get a non-renewal notice in the mail that makes your heart skip a beat, don’t panic just yet. California has a mandatory one-year moratorium on non-renewals that kicks in when there’s a state-declared emergency nearby. It protects your ZIP code from being dropped solely because a tree looked at an underwriter the wrong way.
We’re all in this high-premium boat together. If you need help navigating the paperwork or just want to vent about the cost of joist-hardening, call me at 408-316- 1666 or email Keith.Kanady@Compass. com. I’m here to help with all your real estate needs and to keep your mountain dream from becoming a mathematical nightmare.
